• Home
  • Services
  • Projects
  • Clients
  • About
  • Writing & Research
  • Contact
Menu

Barbara Rosen Consulting

Street Address
City, State, Zip
Phone Number
Social Impact Consulting

Your Custom Text Here

Barbara Rosen Consulting

  • Home
  • Services
  • Projects
  • Clients
  • About
  • Writing & Research
  • Contact

Chaos-Informed Living

January 20, 2022 Barbara Rosen

Writing & Research

On this page, I write about child care, early learning systems change, and poverty alleviation, with a focus on research-based policies and how they are implemented within programs and communities.

Since we're rounding our way into Year 3 (!) of this pandemic, I thought I'd take a moment to discuss what we like to call around our house "chaos-informed living," or more simply, "chaos theory." Not the actual chaos theory in mathematics and science, but  the gist is somewhat similar: we recognize that the world is filled with uncertainty, but there are some patterns within the chaos that can be observed and even leveraged. If we can recognize some of these patterns, maybe we could make things a bit easier for ourselves.

This idea plays out fairly predictably with our toddler, who in a second will take the piece of fish on her high chair tray and fling it across the room, or toddle swiftly to the counter to grab a lego structure, smashing it into a thousand pieces. One minute the floor has just been cleaned and there is a semblance of order, the next there is lego rubble that presents immediate tripping and choking hazards and will take approximately 30 min to clean. With young kids in an ongoing pandemic, we've been scheming about what"chaos-informed" systems might actually look like in our life right now. How can we harness the patterns of disorder, or at least the sheer inevitability of it? 

We've tried things like planting clover in the yard instead of grass, a weed that likes to spread everywhere and thrives in the Seattle rain, so that it will just cover up other dirt patches as they inevitably arise, rather than maintaining the lawn all year. (Sidebar: We didn't come up with this idea ourselves, my husband has been watching YouTube videos on permaculture in his downtime as part of his efforts to prepare for the apocalypse). Or for example, removing the high chair tray when our toddler stops eating, but before she starts flinging the fish (also, spoon-feeding her fish, or just don’t with the fish. This perhaps should have been obvious, but here we are). Before purchasing a toy or light fixture or rug for the house, we've started asking ourselves, "is this decision chaos-informed?" Indoor plants on the floor are a no. Washable rugs and fabrics are a yes. 

So what does it mean to be chaos-informed anyway? It can look like: observing the ways that things tend to fall into disorder, and setting up systems that prevent the chaos from happening in the first place, or allowing the chaos to exist b/c it is part of a larger system or cycle that is self-fulfilling or limiting. This idea can be traced back to permaculture and indigenous land-use practices: observing patterns in nature and using them to inform the design of man-made ecosystems. Or noticing where changes or disruptions often occur, and timing interventions accordingly.

I think this chaos-informed approach can apply to social policy in some interesting ways:

  • Similar to our toddler, grownups also behave in predictably irrational ways. This is because we are not perfectly rational human beings but also because the world is a complex place and there is often too much choice, and this can negatively affect our decision making. This is summed up well by the discipline of behavioral economics, which addresses the gap between a person's intentions and their actions. This gap is heavily affected by the context for the person making the decision, including how they are feeling that day, how many choices they have to decide between, and what else is going on around them at the time. 

  • For example, when faced with many options for retirement plans, or hoops to jump through to sign up for a benefit like paid parental leave (while also trying to take care of a newborn!), people often don't sign up on time, forget to contribute or collect payments, or might not enroll in the plan that best meets their needs.

By observing and recognizing the common ways that people are influenced by “choice overload” and chaotic circumstances, we can set up systems and structures that make it simpler and easier to take actions that are more aligned with our intentions and goals. Some evidence-based approaches for this include:

  • Removing barriers by making registration for programs and services easy (online registration, multiple languages with tech support), processes automated (direct deposit, auto-enrollment, opt-out policies), and program rules simplified.

  • Providing a small and curated set of options to choose from, based on a couple mental shortcuts (e.g. your age, risk tolerance).

  • The private sector employs many of these strategies to get customers to buy and subscribe and pay attention to things. But when it comes to government and non-profit services these details can be overlooked, even though they can make or break the success of a given program.

Thanks for reading!

-Barb

1 Comment
← Newer Posts

(c) 2023 Barbara Rosen Consulting, LLC — 2400 NW 80th St, Seattle WA 98117